September 3, 2026·5 min read

Search Console Metrics Every Agency Should Report

Search Console is one of the most useful — and most under-reported — data sources agencies have access to. Here's what's actually worth putting in front of a client, and how to talk about organic search movement without setting expectations SEO can't reliably meet month to month.

The metrics worth reporting

  • Total clicks and impressions over time — the baseline visibility trend, best viewed over 3+ months rather than a single period
  • Average position — useful as a trend, less useful as a single snapshot number, since it moves for reasons outside any one campaign
  • Click-through rate — a low CTR on high-impression pages is often a title/meta description problem worth flagging directly
  • Top queries and pages — which searches and pages are actually driving traffic, so a client sees where organic demand exists

Setting the right expectations

Organic search moves slower and noisier than paid — a client used to weekly Meta Ads updates can be unsettled by SEO's normal month-to-month variance if it isn't framed correctly upfront. Reporting the trend over a longer window, rather than reacting to every weekly wiggle, keeps the conversation grounded in what's actually changing.

Combining Search Console with the rest of the picture

Organic clicks mean more next to paid search and overall site traffic — a client can see whether organic is growing on its own or riding alongside a paid push, which changes what "is SEO working" actually means for that period.

Where Reportly fits

Reportly connects to Google Search Console alongside GA4, Google Ads, and Meta Ads, so organic performance shows up in the same report as everything else a client is paying for — with trend charts and an AI-written summary instead of a raw Search Console export.

Connect Search Console and see it in a report — 14-day free trial, no credit card required.